Comparing Performance
How They Compare on the Things That Matter
Both products have useful applications, but their performance characteristics are quite different. Here are the factors we consider when specifying spray foam for Montana homes and buildings.
Thermal Resistance
Closed cell delivers roughly R-7 per inch. Open cell delivers approximately R-3.5 to R-3.7. In a cold climate with limited cavity depth, that gap is decisive. Closed cell can deliver substantially more thermal resistance within the same framing space, making it particularly useful where available depth is limited.
Vapor Control
Closed cell at two inches or more functions as its own vapor barrier. Open cell is vapor permeable and does not provide the same vapor-control characteristics. In a Montana wall assembly, where warm indoor air meeting a cold surface can produce condensation inside the cavity, that permeability is a real consideration.
Air Sealing
Both closed cell and open cell spray foam are excellent air sealants, but closed cell is technically superior because it provides a complete air barrier at a much thinner application.
Structural Contribution
Closed cell bonds hard to studs, sheathing, and steel and adds racking strength to the assembly. Open cell adds nothing structural, by design. The two materials therefore serve different roles when structural contribution is part of the project specification.
Sound Control
Open cell wins here clearly. Its soft, open structure absorbs sound rather than transmitting it, which is why it is the material we reach for when noise is the problem being solved. Interior partition walls, bedroom walls, and floor systems between stories are examples where sound attenuation can be a priority.
Water Contact
Closed cell foam does not absorb water and holds its integrity through minor contact. Open cell foam will take on water, which rules it out for crawl spaces, rim joists, and anywhere with moisture exposure.
Expansion and Cavity Fill
Open cell expands far more per unit of material, which is an advantage in awkward cavities and part of why it costs less to fill a given volume. That expansion can make it useful in certain applications where filling irregular spaces and controlling sound are more important than achieving the highest R-value per inch.